All Topics
physics-9702 | as-a-level
Responsive Image
10. Magnetic Fields
27. Quantum Physics
Understand the difference between work done by a gas and work done on a gas

Topic 2/3

left-arrow
left-arrow
archive-add download share

Your Flashcards are Ready!

15 Flashcards in this deck.

or
NavTopLeftBtn
NavTopRightBtn
3
Still Learning
I know
12

Understand the Difference Between Work Done by a Gas and Work Done on a Gas

Introduction

Understanding the distinction between work done by a gas and work done on a gas is fundamental in thermodynamics, particularly within the framework of the First Law of Thermodynamics. This concept is crucial for students pursuing the AS & A Level Physics (9702) curriculum, as it lays the groundwork for analyzing energy transfer processes in various physical systems.

Key Concepts

1. Definition of Work in Thermodynamics

In thermodynamics, work is defined as the energy transfer that occurs when a force is applied over a distance. Specifically, when dealing with gases, work can occur either by the gas or on the gas, depending on the direction of energy transfer.

2. Work Done by a Gas

When a gas expands against an external pressure, it performs work on its surroundings. This process involves the gas molecules pushing against the external pressure, resulting in energy transfer from the gas to the environment.

The mathematical expression for work done by a gas is: $$W = \int_{V_i}^{V_f} P_{\text{ext}} \, dV$$ where:

  • W is the work done by the gas,
  • Vi and Vf are the initial and final volumes, respectively,
  • Pext is the external pressure.

If the external pressure is constant, the equation simplifies to: $$W = P_{\text{ext}} (V_f - V_i)$$ Here, if the gas expands (Vf > Vi), work done by the gas is positive.

**Example:** Consider a gas expanding from 2 liters to 5 liters against a constant external pressure of 1 atmosphere ($1 atm$). The work done by the gas is: $$W = 1 \, \text{atm} \times (5 \, \text{L} - 2 \, \text{L}) = 3 \, \text{L.atm}$$ To convert to joules: $$1 \, \text{L.atm} = 101.325 \, \text{J}$$ Thus, $$W = 3 \times 101.325 \, \text{J} = 303.975 \, \text{J}$$

3. Work Done on a Gas

Conversely, work is done on a gas when the external pressure compresses the gas, transferring energy from the surroundings to the gas.

The work done on the gas is given by the same integral: $$W = \int_{V_i}^{V_f} P_{\text{ext}} \, dV$$ However, in this case, if the gas is compressed (Vf < Vi), the work done on the gas is negative.

**Example:** If a gas is compressed from 5 liters to 2 liters under a constant external pressure of 1 atmosphere (&dollar;1 atm&dollar;), the work done on the gas is: $$W = 1 \, \text{atm} \times (2 \, \text{L} - 5 \, \text{L}) = -3 \, \text{L.atm} = -303.975 \, \text{J}$$ The negative sign indicates that work is done on the gas, increasing its internal energy.

4. Sign Convention in Thermodynamics

Thermodynamics adopts a specific sign convention to maintain consistency:

  • Positive work indicates work done by the system (gas) on the surroundings.
  • Negative work signifies work done on the system (gas) by the surroundings.

5. First Law of Thermodynamics

The First Law of Thermodynamics states that the change in internal energy (ΔU) of a system is equal to the heat (Q) added to the system minus the work (W) done by the system: $$\Delta U = Q - W$$

In the context of work done by or on a gas:

  • If work is done by the gas, ΔU decreases if no heat is added.
  • If work is done on the gas, ΔU increases if no heat is removed.

6. Specific Processes Involving Work

Several thermodynamic processes involve work done by or on a gas, each with distinct characteristics:

  • Isobaric Process: Occurs at constant pressure. Work done can be easily calculated as $W = P (V_f - V_i)$.
  • Isochoric Process: Occurs at constant volume. No work is done since $dV = 0$.
  • Isothermal Process: Occurs at constant temperature. Work done involves integrating over changing volume with $PV = nRT$.
  • Adiabatic Process: Occurs without heat exchange. Work done affects the internal energy directly.

7. Reversible vs. Irreversible Work

Work can be categorized based on the reversibility of the process:

  • Reversible Work: Occurs infinitely slowly, allowing the system to remain in equilibrium. It represents the maximum work obtainable.
  • Irreversible Work: Occurs rapidly, often involving friction or turbulence, resulting in less work being done.

8. Energy Transfer and Efficiency

Understanding work done by and on a gas is essential for evaluating the efficiency of engines and refrigerators. The efficiency depends on how effectively a system converts heat into work or vice versa.

9. Practical Applications

These concepts apply to various real-world systems:

  • Pistons in Engines: Gas expansion and compression directly involve work done by and on the gas.
  • Compressed Gas Systems: Storage and manipulation of gases involve calculating work for compression and expansion.
  • Meteorology: Atmospheric pressure changes involve work done by air masses.

10. Mathematical Derivations

Advanced units often require deriving expressions for work in different processes.

**Isothermal Expansion:** For an ideal gas undergoing an isothermal process (constant temperature), the work done by the gas is: $$W = nRT \ln \left( \frac{V_f}{V_i} \right)$$ where:

  • n is the number of moles,
  • R is the universal gas constant, and
  • T is the absolute temperature.

**Adiabatic Process:** For an adiabatic process (no heat exchange), the work done is: $$W = \frac{P_i V_i - P_f V_f}{\gamma - 1}$$ where:

  • P_i and P_f are initial and final pressures,
  • V_i and V_f are initial and final volumes, and
  • γ is the heat capacity ratio ($C_p/C_v$).

Advanced Concepts

1. Thermodynamic Paths and Path Dependency

Work in thermodynamic processes is path-dependent, meaning the amount of work done depends on the specific path taken during the process, not just the initial and final states. Understanding different paths helps in analyzing system behavior under various constraints.

2. Energy Transfer in Cyclic Processes

In cyclic processes, a system returns to its initial state after a series of transformations. The net work done over a complete cycle is equal to the area enclosed by the cycle on a PV diagram, representing the energy transferred as work.

**Carnot Cycle:** A theoretical model that defines the maximum possible efficiency for a heat engine. It consists of two isothermal processes and two adiabatic processes, illustrating reversible work.

3. Real-World Engine Efficiency

Real engines operate on cycles (e.g., Otto, Diesel, and Brayton cycles) where work done by and on gases determine their efficiency. Comparing these cycles helps in designing more efficient engines.

4. Entropy and Irreversibility

Irreversible work processes increase the entropy of the universe, highlighting the second law of thermodynamics. Analyzing work in such processes provides insights into energy dispersion and system inefficiencies.

5. Work in Multicomponent Systems

In systems with multiple gas components or phases, calculating work requires considering interactions between different components. This complexity arises in chemical reactions and phase transitions.

6. Quantum Considerations of Work

At microscopic scales, work involves quantum states changes and energy level transitions. Quantum thermodynamics explores work at the quantum level, bridging classical concepts with quantum mechanics.

7. Statistical Mechanics Perspective

Statistical mechanics provides a framework for understanding work by analyzing the probability distributions of molecular states. It connects macroscopic thermodynamic quantities with microscopic behaviors.

8. Work-Energy Theorems in Different Frames

Analyzing work from different reference frames (e.g., inertial vs. non-inertial) affects the calculation and interpretation of work done by or on a gas, important in applications like rotating systems.

9. Non-ideal Gas Behavior

Real gases deviate from ideal behavior under high pressure or low temperature. Calculating work for non-ideal gases requires modified equations of state (e.g., Van der Waals equation) to account for interactions between molecules.

10. Technological Applications and Innovations

Advanced technologies such as Stirling engines, fuel cells, and HVAC systems rely on precise calculations of work performed by and on gases. Innovations in these areas enhance energy efficiency and sustainability.

11. Interdisciplinary Connections

The concept of work in thermodynamics intersects with engineering (e.g., mechanical and chemical engineering), environmental science (e.g., energy conversion and climate models), and even economics (e.g., energy markets and resource management).

12. Complex Problem-Solving Techniques

Advanced problems often involve multiple processes, requiring the application of integrals, differential equations, and optimization techniques to determine the total work done in complex scenarios.

13. Experimental Methods for Measuring Work

Experimental setups such as piston-cylinder assemblies and calorimeters are used to measure work done by or on gases. Precision in these measurements is crucial for validating theoretical models.

14. Computational Thermodynamics

Computational tools and simulations allow for the analysis of work in complex systems where analytical solutions are intractable. Software like MATLAB and ANSYS facilitate advanced thermodynamic studies.

15. Historical Development and Theoretical Advances

The understanding of work in gases has evolved through contributions from scientists like James Prescott Joule and Rudolf Clausius, shaping modern thermodynamic theory and applications.

Comparison Table

Aspect Work Done by a Gas Work Done on a Gas
Direction of Energy Transfer From the gas to the surroundings From the surroundings to the gas
Sign Convention Positive Negative
Volume Change Expansion (Vf > Vi) Compression (Vf < Vi)
Internal Energy Change (ΔU) Decreases if no heat is added Increases if no heat is removed
Example Processes Isothermal expansion of gas Isothermal compression of gas
Equations $W = \int P_{\text{ext}} \, dV$, $W = nRT \ln \left( \frac{V_f}{V_i} \right)$ $W = -\int P_{\text{ext}} \, dV$, $W = -\frac{P_i V_i - P_f V_f}{\gamma - 1}$

Summary and Key Takeaways

  • Work done by a gas involves energy transfer during expansion, while work done on a gas occurs during compression.
  • Sign conventions: positive for work by the gas, negative for work on the gas.
  • Understanding these concepts is essential for applying the First Law of Thermodynamics.
  • Advanced studies link work to real-world applications and interdisciplinary fields.

Coming Soon!

coming soon
Examiner Tip
star

Tips

Remember the mnemonic "WBYNOW" to differentiate work By the gas (Positive) vs. work On the gas (Negative). Always sketch a PV diagram to visualize the process direction. Practice integrating under varying pressure conditions to strengthen your problem-solving skills. For exams, double-check your sign conventions to avoid common pitfalls.

Did You Know
star

Did You Know

Did you know that the concept of work in thermodynamics was pivotal in the development of steam engines during the Industrial Revolution? Additionally, the efficiency of modern refrigerators and air conditioners relies heavily on understanding work done on and by gases. Interestingly, black holes also engage in thermodynamic processes where work concepts apply in extreme gravitational fields.

Common Mistakes
star

Common Mistakes

Students often confuse the sign convention, incorrectly assigning positive values to work done on a gas instead of by the gas. Another common error is neglecting to consider changes in external pressure during calculations, leading to inaccurate work values. Additionally, forgetting to use the correct equation for specific processes, like using the isothermal work formula in an adiabatic process, can result in misunderstandings.

FAQ

What is the primary difference between work done by and work done on a gas?
Work done by a gas involves energy transfer during its expansion, while work done on a gas involves energy transfer during its compression.
How does the sign convention work in thermodynamics for work?
Positive work indicates work done by the gas on the surroundings, and negative work indicates work done on the gas by the surroundings.
Why is work important in the First Law of Thermodynamics?
Work is a key form of energy transfer that, along with heat, affects the internal energy of a system, as described by the First Law: ΔU = Q - W.
Can work done by a gas be zero?
Yes, during an isochoric process where volume remains constant, no work is done by or on the gas.
How do real gases differ from ideal gases in terms of work?
Real gases deviate from ideal behavior at high pressures or low temperatures, requiring modified equations of state like the Van der Waals equation to accurately calculate work.
What role does external pressure play in calculating work?
External pressure determines the force exerted during expansion or compression, directly influencing the amount of work done by or on the gas.
10. Magnetic Fields
27. Quantum Physics
Download PDF
Get PDF
Download PDF
PDF
Share
Share
Explore
Explore
How would you like to practise?
close